While it is technically possible to eat a goldfish, it is not a common practice, nor is it recommended. Goldfish are considered an ornamental pet fish.
If you are looking for fish to eat, there are numerous other species that are commonly raised and prepared for human consumption, such as trout, salmon, cod, tuna, and many more.
Is It OK to Eat a Goldfish?
It is generally not recommended or considered acceptable to eat a wild goldfish or pet goldfish. These aquarium fish are usually kept as pets or for decorative purposes and are not raised or prepared for human consumption.
Goldfish (Carassius auratus) are a member of the carp family, Cyprinidae. Carp are a diverse group of freshwater fish species that includes various types and breeds, including common carp, koi carp, and goldfish.
Unlike goldfish and koi carp, common carp is known for its suitability as a food fish. It has firm, white flesh and is often prepared by baking, frying, grilling, or in traditional dishes such as gefilte fish in Jewish cuisine or carp soup in Central and Eastern European cuisines.
Reasons Not to Eat a Goldfish
- Health and Safety Concerns: Goldfish may carry diseases, parasites, or other pathogens that could be harmful if consumed by humans. They are not raised or regulated as food fish, so their safety for consumption cannot be guaranteed.
- Unappetizing and Inefficient: Goldfish are not bred or raised for their taste or quality as food. Their flesh tends to be softer and less flavorful than other fish species commonly consumed. Additionally, goldfish have a high proportion of bones compared to their edible flesh, making them inefficient to consume.
- Ethical Considerations: Goldfish are often kept as pets and are valued for their beauty and companionship. Eating a goldfish can be seen as disrespectful or cruel to the animal and goes against the common understanding of keeping them as pets.
What Does Cooked Goldfish Taste Like?
Cooked goldfish, while it is not a common or widely consumed food, has been described by some individuals who have tried it as having a bland or mild flavor. The flesh of goldfish is generally soft and delicate.
So Is It Safe to Eat Goldfish?
No, it is not safe to eat goldfish.
Goldfish may carry diseases, parasites, or other harmful bacteria. Goldfish are freshwater fish that are kept in aquariums or ponds and may be exposed to various contaminants, such as chemicals or pollutants, which can accumulate in their bodies.
Consuming such contaminated fish can pose health risks.
Why Do Some People Eat Goldfish?
While it is generally not common or widely accepted, some individuals may choose to eat goldfish for various reasons.
Some people may be intrigued by the idea of eating a non-traditional or unusual food item like goldfish. They may see it as an adventurous or unique culinary experience.
Certain cultures or regions may have historical or traditional practices of consuming various types of fish, including goldfish. These practices are typically specific to certain communities and may not be widespread or widely accepted.
For example, in some parts of China, particularly during special occasions or festivals like the Chinese New Year, eating steamed or deep-fried large goldfish may be considered a symbol of good luck and prosperity. It is believed that consuming goldfish-shaped pastries or candies, often made from ingredients like red bean paste or rice flour, brings about fortune and auspiciousness.
Traditional Japanese cuisine has a practice called “kingyo sashimi” where live goldfish are temporarily placed in a bowl of water and consumed raw. This practice, which dates back to the Edo period, is considered controversial and is not widely accepted in modern times due to concerns about animal welfare and the potential health risks associated with consuming live fish.
It’s important to reiterate that while some individuals may choose to eat goldfish, it is not considered a safe or recommended practice.
What to read next: Can You Eat A Cobia Fish?
